The appearance of a product can be one of a company’s most valuable assets. Its shape, lines, colours or ornamentation may distinguish it from competing products and represent a considerable investment in creativity, development and innovation.
Design law provides specific mechanisms to protect that appearance and prevent third parties from using it without authorisation.
In Spain and the European Union, there are different forms of protection: national industrial designs registered with the Spanish Patent and Trademark Office (OEPM), registered European Union designs filed with the EUIPO, and unregistered European Union designs.
Although these forms of protection share certain requirements, they differ significantly in their territorial scope, duration and the rights they confer.
What Is an Industrial Design and What Can Be Protected?
An industrial design protects the appearance of the whole or part of a product resulting from features such as its lines, contours, colours, shape, texture, materials or ornamentation.
Protection may extend to products in a wide range of sectors, including furniture, lighting, fashion, footwear, packaging, decorative articles and industrial components.
For example, the particular shape of a chair, the design of a bottle, the appearance of packaging or certain graphic elements applied to a product may qualify for protection.
It is important to distinguish between a product’s appearance and its technical functioning.
Design rights protect features of appearance, rather than technical solutions as such. Where the relevant legal requirements are met, technical solutions may instead be protected through other forms of industrial property, such as patents or utility models.
Furthermore, design protection does not necessarily depend on a product having particular artistic merit. What matters is whether the applicable legal requirements are satisfied.
What Requirements Must a Design Meet to Be Protected?
Both Spanish legislation and European Union law establish two fundamental requirements: novelty and individual character.
Novelty
A design is considered new if no identical design has previously been made available to the public before the relevant date for determining protection.
Designs are considered identical where their features differ only in immaterial details.
Before applying for registration, it is therefore advisable to investigate whether earlier designs exist that could affect the novelty of the proposed design.
Individual Character
A design has individual character if the overall impression it produces on the informed user differs from the overall impression produced by relevant earlier designs.
This assessment requires consideration of the design’s overall appearance and cannot be limited to identifying minor differences in isolation.
The designer’s degree of freedom must also be taken into account, since certain sectors or products may be subject to technical or functional constraints affecting their appearance.
Novelty and individual character are essential requirements for both registered designs and unregistered European Union designs.
How Can an Industrial Design Be Registered in Spain?
National industrial design protection is primarily governed by Spanish Act 20/2003 of 7 July on the Legal Protection of Industrial Designs.
Applications are filed with the Spanish Patent and Trademark Office (OEPM) and provide exclusive rights within Spanish territory.
An application must identify the applicant and include representations of the design that clearly establish the appearance for which protection is sought.
The quality and accuracy of these representations are particularly important, as they help define the subject matter of the registered right.
The registration procedure does not involve an exhaustive examination of novelty and individual character against all earlier designs. Consequently, registration does not prevent the design’s validity from being challenged subsequently.
How Long Does a Registered Spanish Design Last?
A registered industrial design in Spain has an initial term of five years from the filing date.
Registration may be renewed for successive five-year periods, up to a maximum of 25 years.
During its term of protection, the holder may prevent certain unauthorised acts involving products incorporating designs that fall within the scope of the registered right.
These acts may include manufacturing, offering, placing on the market, importing, exporting or stocking products for those purposes.
How Can a European Union Design Be Registered?
Where a company markets, or intends to market, its products in several Member States, it may be advisable to apply for a registered European Union design.
Applications are filed with the European Union Intellectual Property Office (EUIPO) and provide unitary protection throughout the territory of the European Union.
Unlike Spanish national registration, this system does not require separate applications in each Member State to obtain protection across the EU.
It may be particularly useful for companies selling products in different European markets or conducting international business.
As with national registration, the application must properly identify the design and include representations that establish the subject matter of protection.
How Long Does a Registered European Union Design Last?
A registered European Union design has an initial term of five years from the filing date.
It may be renewed for successive five-year periods, up to a maximum of 25 years.
The holder enjoys an exclusive right to prevent unauthorised use of designs that do not produce a different overall impression on the informed user, subject to the limitations established by the applicable legislation.
An important feature of registered design protection is that the holder does not need to prove that a third party deliberately copied the design.
Independent creation does not, in itself, exclude infringement of a registered design.
What Is an Unregistered European Union Design?
One of the distinctive features of the European system is that certain designs may receive protection without any application for registration.
This is known as an unregistered European Union design, a form of protection that is particularly relevant to sectors characterised by short product life cycles or frequent new collections.
Protection arises when a design that satisfies the applicable legal requirements is first made available to the public within the European Union under the conditions established by EU law.
Disclosure may take place through publication, exhibition, commercial use or other forms of making the design available to the public, provided that these events could reasonably have become known, in the normal course of business, to the circles specialised in the sector concerned operating within the European Union.
The mere existence of a design, or its internal development by a company, is therefore insufficient.
A legally relevant disclosure must have occurred.
How Long Does an Unregistered EU Design Last?
An unregistered European Union design is protected for three years from the date on which it was first made available to the public within the European Union.
Unlike registered designs, this protection cannot be renewed.
Its limited duration reflects the purpose of protecting products whose commercial exploitation may be concentrated within relatively short periods.
What Rights Does an Unregistered EU Design Confer?
The most significant difference compared with registered designs concerns the scope of the exclusive right.
The holder of an unregistered European Union design may prevent unauthorised use where that use results from copying the protected design.
However, infringement does not arise where the contested design results from independent creation by a designer who could reasonably be considered not to have been familiar with the earlier design.
This distinction has important practical consequences.
While registered design protection may be enforced against designs falling within its scope even where they were independently created, enforcement of an unregistered design requires consideration of whether copying has occurred.
How Can the Existence of an Unregistered Design Be Proven?
In the event of a dispute, the holder must be able to establish the facts supporting the claimed protection.
It is particularly important to preserve evidence of the date and circumstances of the design’s first disclosure, together with documentation identifying its features.
Relevant evidence may include commercial catalogues, dated publications, photographs from trade fairs, websites, advertising materials and documentation relating to the product’s launch or commercialisation.
It will also be necessary to examine the circumstances supporting the allegation that the third party’s use resulted from copying.
The absence of a registration certificate makes the preservation of evidence especially important from the earliest stages of commercial exploitation.
Is There a Separate Spanish National Unregistered Design Right?
Spanish legislation establishes a national system for registering industrial designs with the OEPM.
There is no separate Spanish national unregistered design right equivalent to the unregistered European Union design.
However, designs that meet the requirements of the European regime may benefit from unregistered EU design protection in Spain without being registered with either the OEPM or the EUIPO.
Depending on the circumstances, the appearance of a product may also receive protection under other legal provisions, including unfair competition law or, where the relevant requirements are met, copyright law.
These mechanisms should not be confused with the specific protection afforded to unregistered designs, and their application requires a separate legal assessment.
What Are the Differences Between Spanish Registered Designs, Registered EU Designs and Unregistered EU Designs?
The three forms of protection have important differences that should be considered when deciding how to protect a product’s appearance.
| Feature | Spanish registered design | Registered EU design | Unregistered EU design |
|---|---|---|---|
| Registration authority | OEPM | EUIPO | No registration required |
| Territorial scope | Spain | European Union | European Union |
| Duration | Up to 25 years | Up to 25 years | 3 years |
| Renewal | Every 5 years | Every 5 years | Not renewable |
| Requirements | Novelty and individual character | Novelty and individual character | Novelty and individual character |
| Protection against independent creation | Yes, within the scope of the right | Yes, within the scope of the right | No; copying is required |
The choice between these forms of protection will depend on factors such as the markets in which the company operates, the expected commercial life of the product, the economic value of the design and the risk of reproduction by third parties.
Can a Design Be Registered After It Has Been Disclosed?
An important question arises when a company publicly presents a product before applying to register its design.
Both Spanish legislation and EU law provide, under certain conditions, a 12-month grace period for certain disclosures made by the designer, their successor in title, or as a result of information provided or action taken by either of them.
This grace period may allow registration without certain earlier disclosures destroying the design’s novelty or individual character.
However, it should not be interpreted as a general authorisation to disclose any design without consequences.
The application of the grace period depends on the specific circumstances of disclosure and compliance with the relevant legal requirements.
It is also important to distinguish between the grace period for filing a registration application and the three-year duration of unregistered EU design protection.
A company cannot wait until the three-year period of unregistered design protection has expired and assume that the design can then be validly registered.
Companies intending to commercialise a new product should therefore establish their design protection strategy before making it public.
What Should You Do If Another Company Copies an Industrial Design?
When a company discovers that a competitor is marketing products reproducing the appearance of one of its designs, the first step is to determine which rights may be relied upon.
Where a registered design exists, it is necessary to verify its validity and continued registration, examine the representations included in the registration and assess the scope of the protection conferred.
Where protection is claimed on the basis of an unregistered European Union design, the analysis must address the first disclosure, compliance with the requirements for protection and the circumstances supporting the allegation of copying.
In both cases, the designs must be compared by reference to the overall impression they produce on the informed user and the designer’s degree of freedom.
Depending on the circumstances, legal remedies may include injunctions to stop infringement, withdrawal of products from the market or compensation for damage suffered, subject to the requirements of the applicable legislation.
The appropriate course of action requires an assessment of both the existence and validity of the right and the available evidence concerning the third party’s conduct.
The Importance of a Design Protection Strategy
Industrial design protection should form part of the intellectual property strategy of companies developing and marketing products with a distinctive appearance.
Although unregistered European Union design protection arises automatically in certain circumstances, its limited duration and the need to establish copying may make enforcement more difficult.
National or European registration, by contrast, provides greater legal certainty and allows protection to be maintained for a longer period.
At HERNANDEZ MARTI Abogados, we advise companies on industrial design matters, including the protection and registration of designs and the enforcement of their rights against potential infringements.
Our services include assessing the validity and scope of design rights, proceedings before the OEPM and the EUIPO, and resolving disputes concerning unauthorised use of designs in Spain and throughout the European Union.
